MLB Data Warehouse

MLB Data Warehouse

MLB DW Slate Preview - May 21

My rundown of today's MLB slate, including full projections and analysis for each game

Jon A's avatar
Jon A
May 21, 2025
∙ Paid
1
Share

Night Slate

Pitchers

Braves vs. Nationals is at risk of a wash out - and there are pretty crappy conditions in the Rangers/Yankees game as well. Keep an eye on that stuff.

  • Jacob deGrom ($10,000) vs. Yankees: This is a showdown. Should be a fun game to watch. deGrom’s strikeout rate is under 27%, very strange for him, but he still has a top-notch 16.6% SwStr% and 32.7% Ball%. The strikeouts are going to come, and he’s got big upside against this heavy-swinging Yankees squad.

  • Garrett Crochet ($10,500) vs. Mets: Not the easiest matchup in the world, and the price is still way up there. But the model is feeling better about Crochet now and it doesn’t hate even this $10.5K on him against the Mets.

  • Tylor Megill ($8,300) vs. Red Sox: Megill projects for 6.8 strikeouts, which is actually a little bit more than deGrom and just under Crochet. His command isn’t good, which gives him a lot lwoer of a floor than those other two - but the guy can strike hitters out. For $8,300 - he could be a key piece tonight if the command is there.

  • Carson Palmquist ($5,000) vs. Phillies: The model does believe in Palmquist as an above-average MLB strikeout pitcher. Everything else might be terrible, but the projection on him is a solid 14 points for the $5K price. It’s extremely risky, but the price is enticing.

Stacks

  • Dodgers vs. Corbin Burnes: Burnes goes from the easiest matchup in the league (struck out ten Rockies at home last time out) to one of the toughest. And he has not looked good this year except for in that Road Rockies start. I think we can jump on a lower-owned LAD stack against him.

  • Rockies vs. Taijuan Walker: The Rockies finally get a break after facing two tough Phillies lefties in the first two games of the series. Walker is not good and the Rockies should be able to get some balls in play against him tonight and let Coors Field do its work.

  • Athletics vs. Jack Kochanowicz: The A’s have guys that can hit thel ongball. They also have a lot of strikeout in their lineup, but that isn’t a concern against J-KOCH, who is one of the lowest K pitchers you’ll find in the Major Leagues.

  • Angels vs. JP Sears: Sears’ struggles with right-handed bats are clear. And the Angels have at least a few competent righties in their lineup. Ward, Soler, and Neto are in play here.

  • Phillies vs. Palmquist: The model likes Palmquist, so it doesn’t grade the Phillies out very well for what they’re priced. But you can’t deny a Phillies stack on this slate. Chances are they’ll do just fine, and even if Palmquist pitches well - the Rockies bullpen is awful behind him.

Top Bats

Catcher

  1. O’Hoppe $3,700 vs. Sears

  2. Langeliers $4,000 vs. Kochanowicz

  3. Kirk $3,100 vs. Vasquez

First Base

  1. Ohtani $6,300 vs. Burnes

  2. Guerrero Jr. $4,700 vs. Vasquez

  3. Olson $4,600 vs. Williams

Second Base

  1. Rengifo $2,600 vs. Sears

  2. Hamilton $2,700 vs. Megill

  3. Marte $5,600 vs. May

Third Base

  1. McMahon $3,800 vs. Walker

  2. Muncy $3,200 vs. Burnes

  3. Riley $4,400 vs. Williams

Shortstop

  1. Neto $4,600 vs. Sears

  2. Tovar $3,100 vs. Walker

  3. Abrams $5,100 vs. Smith-Shawver

  4. Turner $6,200 vs. Palmquist

Outfield

  1. Ohtani $6,300 vs. Burnes

  2. Carroll $5,900 vs. May

  3. Soderstrom $4,500 vs. Koch

  4. Butler $4,300 vs. Koch

  5. Ward $3,500 vs. Sears

  6. Haggerty $4,300 vs. Yarbrough

  7. Wood $4,800 vs. Smith-Shawver

  8. Rooker $5,000 vs. Koch

  9. Tatis Jr. $5,700 vs. Gausman

  10. Adell $2,800 vs. Sears

  11. Beck $4,800 vs. Walker

  12. Varsho $4,200 vs. Vasquez

  13. Soler $3,400 vs. Sears


Early Slate

Pitchers

  • Hunter Brown ($10,500) vs. Rays: Pretty much have to do on this slate. There’s not much to like. We have the situation where there is clearly a top SP on the board head-and-shoulder above the rest, and that’s Brown against the Rays. Great spot for him and no weather issues down there in Florida.

  • Cade Horton ($8,000) vs. Marlins: I don’t believe Horton to be a great MLB pitcher. I think he’ll prove to be more of an SP3-SP4, but against the Marlins on this particular slate I think we can play him for the first time. It’s another game that doesn’t have weather concerns, and the Marlins are a great matchup for Horton and his mid-90s fastball and slider.

  • Shane Smith ($7,000) vs. Mariners: Smith has looked good, and particularly lately. He has 17 strikeouts and just three runs allowed in his last 16 innings (three starts). The Mariners don’t look like a pushover matchup this year, but that doesn’t mean we have to avoid them. The M’s are slashing .236/.321/.397 this year. That’s about a league-average line overall. I like Smith’s fastball and changeup, and I think the stuff he has gives him a 4-5 strikeout floor here, which works okay for the price on this tough slate.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Jon A
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture