> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.mlbdatawarehouse.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Stupid Early ADP - Third Base
- URL: https://www.mlbdatawarehouse.com/stupid-early-adp-third-base/
- Published: 2026-11-17T15:11:00.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-17T15:10:59.000Z
- Author: Jon Anderson
- Tags: 2027 Draft Prep, Early ADP

[**Read the full series here**](https://www.mlbdatawarehouse.com/tag/early-adp/)

Someone has finally cleared **Jose Ramirez**, who has been #1 at the position every year since 2023, which is as far back as I looked. 

It's **Junior Caminero** as the lone third baseman in the top ten. 

But it's a pretty ugly picture. Five third basemen in the top 50 right now, but then nobody between 50 and 100 in ADP. 

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/32/22/322212fc-720a-4899-891b-079f5343fd5b/content/images/2026/11/image-228.png)

Those five in the top 100 are:

- Junior Caminero
- Jose Ramirez
- Sal Stewart
- Miguel Vargas
- Kevin McGonigle

Stewart, Vargas, and McGonigle all have eligibility at another position, but you'll almost surely be wanting to use them at third since this position has so little to offer.

And there are issues with everybody but Caminero at the top. I'm going to be harsh here and give you mostly the bad news.

**Jose Ramirez** is coming off a year where he hit .235 with 12 homers. His EV fell a bit (and it was never very high), he landed at just a .325 xwOBA, and he came in under 40 steals for the first time in the last three seasons. So the only real fantasy tool we saw last year (the steals) is hard to count on since he's 34 years old. The reason to believe in a bounce-back is that his HR/FB was cut in half last year and he landed 20-30 points below his normal BABIP. There's a mix of loss of physical skill with bad luck. I think he can land in between his 2025 and 2026 production in 2027, and that's what the projection and ADP will say as well.

**Sal Stewart** really stopped running on the bases after the first couple months. I don't think he's really a 15-steal guy moving forward. And he drove in 111 runs on a bad team, so I think that was inflated as well by well-timed extra base hits. I could see a real fall off to 27-homers and ten steals with that .260ish batting average. 

**Miguel Vargas** did it all last year. It's hard to poke any holes in the numbers from a year ago, but we have this history before last year where it wasn't very good. And his exit velocities don't really support the 33-homer season. So I see him coming in a bit below 30 homers as well, and I could see a slight drop off on the 22 steals as well. He's just not the most physically gifted dude, so he really has to do everything right to repeat. 

**Kevin McGonigle** gives you relatively few homers and steals for a guy going in the top 50 picks. He makes that up with batting average, OBP, run scoring, and general safety - but most of the guys drafted around him can at least get to 35 HR+SB, and I don't really see that from him. 

That is all super nitpicky, though. I think they're all fine picks. But it does make me like the idea of bagging Junior Caminero in the first round and not having to deal with these decisions. 

---

You travel 40 picks down the list before getting to this:

- Zack Gelof 107
- Alex Bregman 115
- Manny Machado 115

**Zack Gelof** did improve tremendously in plate discipline. That was the thing that kept him out of the MLB picture. But it's still not great with a 25% K% and 7% BB%. He is pretty aggressive and has always been a guy to have big-time slumps. But he would've easily gone 20-20 in a full season (22 homers, 16 steals in 111 games), and he gets one more year in that joke of a ballpark in Sacramento. 

**Alex Bregman** looked like a total dud for the first couple of months but then teamed up with PCA to carry their offense. 

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/32/22/322212fc-720a-4899-891b-079f5343fd5b/content/images/2026/11/image-229.png)

His 28 homers were the most since back in 2019 with the juiced balls and playing in Houston. I'm not betting on that to repeat, and he's not a steals guy or a guy who hits much above .260\. He's certainly safe, but the 8th round price isn't super appealing to me. 

**Manny Machado** hit freaking .217 with a .243 xBA. So there's some bad luck there, but he's old and he plays in a tough ballpark. He stole just five bags. It really looks like the age (34) is getting to him. It's another fine bounce-back bet, but he hasn't been a true fantasy stud in years, so you're hoping for him to bounce back to just being like "pretty good". 

---

**Kazuma Okamoto** is next and sort of on an ADP island around 140\. There's 20 picks to get to the next guys. He played 156 games, got to 636 PAs, and jammed out 33 homers. But the .232 average with the 29% K% makes him a Max Muncy type player. He stole one bag. So you're just hoping he hits you 30+ bangers again, and that's no guarantee with a guy who swings and misses this much. 

---

That's the top nine. To show it in a list:

1. Junior Caminero
2. Jose Ramirez
3. Sal Stewart
4. Miguel Vargas
5. Kevin McGonigle
6. Zack Gelof
7. Alex Bregman
8. Manny Machado
9. Kazuma Okamoto

After that, there's this group that are all very similar. And they're all very similar in their do-nothingness. 

1. Maikel Garcia
2. Bryson Stott
3. Bo Bichette
4. Curtis Mead
5. Casey Schmitt

"Do nothing" isn't exactly right, but you get what I mean. **Maikel Garcia** doesn't hit homers and in his most recent data we've seen the steals really falling off as well.

**Bryson Stott** is a mid-20s seteals guy, but offers very little besides that. 

**Bo Bichette** hit .260 last year with 18 homers and two steals. His SLG fell 90 points last year. 

**Curtis Mead** might had an awesome 87-game sample with the Nationals, but then we lost him after one game with the Red Sox. He hit 17 homers in those 87 games with the Nats, so that's very interesting. It's hard to believe that he can continue anything like that, and the price shows that drafters don't really believe it either - but I'd rather take a shot on him rather than these other guys. 

I do see **Casey Schmitt** as a good value at 3B 14\. He hit 21 homers and swiped nine bags in just 98 games last year before an injury. Very similar to Mead with the surprising break out in half of a season. And he has to deal with AT&T Park and a bad lineup around him, but there seems to be a lot more upside with Mead and Schmitt, so I'd be down to start the year with one of those guys at the hot corner. 

---

The next grouping:

- Isaac Paredes
- Brooks Lee
- Austin Riley

Paredes and Lee are much different-looking players, but their production comes out pretty evenly. Some dingers with low batting average and steals. Neither of them hit the ball hard but they pull enough balls in the air to hit some dingers. It's really rough to rely on that profile as a starter. 

And **Austin Riley** just had a disaster season, hitting .219 with 19 homers in 159 games. That power is still in there somewhere, but now it's been three full seasons without going above 20 homers (although injuries were mostly to blame for that in 2024 and 2025).

---

**Teruaki Sato** will be landing in the MLB in the next couple of weeks. I wrote about him here:

[International Arrivals to KnowWe get a handful of players coming over from Japan/Korea every winter. We saw some big impact from Munetaka Murakami and Kazuma Okamoto last year. The pitchers recently haven't made a huge impact, but there are some gems like Yoshinobu Yamamoto in recent years. We'll try to![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/32/22/322212fc-720a-4899-891b-079f5343fd5b/content/images/icon/mlbdw_logo_2026-44ca0a75-6a30-46e6-b0f8-ccb722d26362.jpg)MLB Data WarehouseJon Anderson![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/32/22/322212fc-720a-4899-891b-079f5343fd5b/content/images/thumbnail/2027-arrivals-to-know-68921f38-9986-4825-bbae-f51a7a388453.png)](https://www.mlbdatawarehouse.com/international-arrivals-to-know/)

Long story short, maybe he'll be relevant at 3B this year, but it's very uncertain and it doesn't look like there's a ton of upside with him. 

He forms a trio with **Coby Mayo** and **Royce Lewis** in the 230-240 range. Mayo has a lot of work to do against right handed pitchers, but if he can figure that out even a little bit, he should give you a good supply of homers. Because he's one of the best hitters in the league against lefties. Here's last year's OPS leaders vs. LHP:

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/32/22/322212fc-720a-4899-891b-079f5343fd5b/content/images/2026/11/image-248.png)

He hit .177/.244/.32 against righties, so you don't want him in your lineup during a week where the Orioles see 4-5 righties. 

**Royce Lewis** might be my flag plant. I just wrote the Twins preview, and I'm really interested in Lewis as a 20-20 threat. But you'll have to have a backup plan with his injury history. 

---

After that, it's a bunch of guys who aren't every day players. Ezequiel Duran, Max Muncy, Javier Sanoja, Caleb Durbin, Brett Baty, etc. 

It's very thin. 

---

I think my strategy would be to get a guy early, or just use the position to plan ahead and get a specialist. Stott for steals, Okamoto for homers, Austin Riley as a cheap flier hoping he can bounce back. Something like that. I'm not seeing many fantastic breakout picks after pick 100\. 

And if you draft a Vargas, McGonigle, Stewart, Gelof - just make sure you plan your draft out where you're definitely starting them at 3B rather than their other positions. 

---

# ADP 300+

At least we have some dudes that will play in the early 300s:

- Nolan Arenado 305
- Alec Bohm (landing spot pending, he's a FA) 319
- Matt Chapman 322
- Brendan Donovan 388
- Nick Gonzales 419

None of those names sound bad to me as a strategy to sort of punt the position. You can get some batting average from Gonzales and Donovan at least. 

Some guys with upside:

**Blaze Alexander**: He hit .303/.351/.414 in 188 PAs with four homers. But something will need to break his way to get him regular starts. [**The Lineup Report**](https://thelineupreport.com/projected/110?ref=mlbdatawarehouse.com) has him every day vs. LHP and the "majority regular" against RHP in the outfield. But the Orioles roster is very much in flux and could change a lot this offseason. 

**Christian Encarnacion-Strand** also did a pretty nice job hitting for power in his re-emergence to the bigs with the Orioles. He'll be in there against lefties, but might not see regular reps against righties with Pete Alonso obviously manning first base every day. 

I don't hate **Kyle Karros** as much as the Rockies might. They didn't commit to him as a full-time player. [**He's another guy that's in there against lefties and part time against righties, mostly hitting lower in the batting order**](https://thelineupreport.com/player/691720?ref=mlbdatawarehouse.com). 

![](https://storage.ghost.io/c/32/22/322212fc-720a-4899-891b-079f5343fd5b/content/images/2026/11/image-249.png)

But he's a good defender and hit .253/.345/.414 with some power (13 homers in 131 games, 8.3% Brl%). If he can play 140+ games, I think he'll have a pretty nice season, but that sort of playing time probably won't happen. 

---

# Prospects

**Caleb Bonemer** is one of the game's top hitting prospects. 37 homers last year in just 130 games, plus 17 steals. He did not reach AAA, though, so he'll have to spend at least a few weeks there, and probably more. There's a contact / K% issue with him. So he's pretty similar to **Colson Montgomery**, and we've seen how that can go. 

**Andrew Fischer** might be the Brewers' long-term first baseman, but he's 3B-eligible only on NFBC. **48 homers** last year in 126 games. Same story as Bonemer: he hasn't been to AAA yet, and he strikes out a lot. But he has ridiculous power and is going to be a must-add guy as soon as he's called up, just to see if that can play. 

So those are the big names of the future at the position, at least in terms of home runs. But I don't see any sort of guarantee that they matter for fantasy leagues in 2027\. Very unlikely to make the team right away, and both are probably .220 hitters or so out of the gate as they adjust. 

One safer, but less exciting, option is **Jefferson Rojas**. He was traded from the Cubs to the Mets and got to AAA at the end of the year. He hit 27 homers and swiped 20 bags last year, so it was a nice season. He doesn't quite have the same raw tools as some of the other top prospects in the game, but his 17.6% K% and 8.6% BB% last year show discipline that could make his transition to the Majors a little smoother.